The McKinsey Quarterly

close Visitor Edition

McKinsey Quarterly is the business journal of McKinsey & Company.

  • Recommend (60)
  • Text Size
  • Print
  • Download PDF
  • Link to This

Women and leadership: Learning from the social sector

Jacqueline Novogratz, CEO of Acumen Fund, shares lessons in leadership from her work in venture philanthropy.

As a venture philanthropist, Acumen Fund’s Jacqueline Novogratz leads entrepreneurial projects across the globe—many of which put women at the helm of emerging local businesses. In this video interview, she discusses her experience developing other women leaders, the way they have shaped her own approach to leadership, and the different leadership cultures she sees at play in the public and private sectors.

This interview was conducted by Bill Javetski, an editor with the McKinsey Quarterly, in February 2009. It was recorded in the New York office of Acumen Fund.

To use the video player, please install the Adobe Flash Player plugin version 9 or greater.
Video: Women and leadership—Learning from the social sector
Jacqueline Novogratz shares lessons in leadership from her work in venture philanthropy.

The Quarterly: One of the secrets of your activity in building entrepreneurialism is focusing on women as workers. Can you talk about that?

Jacqueline Novogratz: I had been in Rwanda where I worked with a small group of women to start the first microfinance organization in the country and, simultaneously, a bakery with 20 unwed mothers. My own background has taught me a lot about the power of investing in women, because you do end up feeding a family and not just an individual.

I worry actually that the international-development community may, in focusing so much on the women, end up demoralizing and devaluing men even further. I don’t want to be glib about just investing in girls. We have to build healthy societies and we have to recognize that boys and girls develop differently and [we have to] find ways really to include, to value, to have high expectations, and to provide opportunity.

And so there’s this big, philosophical question around how do you hire, how do you encourage different behavior. Can you—in the dormitories—bring in other activities to bring in reproductive health, to help with microfinance and savings? There’s a really interesting platform here.

The Quarterly: Your story of the bakery in Rwanda was in large part a story about developing the women that you worked with there. What did you learn about leadership from their experience of developing into owners and operators of that business?

Jacqueline Novogratz: I went in as a leader with pure audaciousness. I didn’t have as much humility in that I just assumed—I’m the eldest of seven, I can do the Bad News Bears thing really well, I’m just going to cheer them on—without having the humility of really understanding what their starting place was.

After many mishaps, including having them steal from me and having them not really know how to sell—I mean they would look down the whole time and have to explain to me that they were considered prostitutes by many; for them to go and look somebody directly in the eye and shake their hands was not exactly a Rwandan-woman kind of thing—so I had to learn to have the humility myself to really listen to their perspectives, and yet not stop there; to have the audaciousness to say, “It’s a good starting point, but we want to get you to this other place.”

The real lesson for me was how that dignity is so much more important to the human spirit than wealth. And that what these women, as all of us, needed was to know that we could cover basic needs, but to have the power of being able to say no to things that we didn’t want, that we didn’t want to do. And so leadership as a way of inspiring, listening, and letting people, you know, grow themselves in their own way.

And it was a small experience in some ways, and yet one that I think about all the time that taught me so much about listening and dignity—and laughter as a really, really key component. The more stressed I got, the less anything worked; and the more we could laugh, the more we got done. And so that was probably another really big lesson.

I’m a big optimist. I really believe in setting impossible goals and then making them possible. And I really love people—and I think people feel that from me. So it’s probably that sometimes very confusing mix of optimism, idealism, but also high expectations, lots of discipline, and pragmatism.

Part of the journey that those of us who are privileged, which is pretty much everyone in this country, has to make is not being embarrassed by privilege or guilty for privilege or confused by privilege, but to start from that place of recognizing that your responsibility is to use that privilege in the best way you can to serve the world. And there are lots of ways of serving the world.

The Quarterly: Many women work in social sector, fewer in finance. Let’s say actually fewer lead in finance. You’ve succeeded in both. Any thoughts on the skill set, and why one isn’t more prevalent in the other area?

Jacqueline Novogratz: I think that girls really are relational, and what I love about finance—and what I love about accounting even, which is kind of embarrassing to admit—is it’s another form of storytelling. And if you could teach young people to find the stories in the combination of the balance sheet and the income statement, I think we would see a lot more girls taking leadership in finding that comfort.

I just did a panel for women on Wall Street, and what they spoke about was how rigid our financial institutions continue to be around integrating women into the workforce—particularly after they’ve had children—and that the rules are so driven by a different kind of discipline that the social sector has taken upon itself to reinvent. And that may be more to the point as to why we don’t see as many leaders—women leaders—in finance. It’s a much older club. It’s been driven by a stricter set of rules and expectations.

I have four brothers who all work on Wall Street, and I remember when one of my brothers’ wife had a child. And I said, “Well, is there, you know, paternity leave?” And he said, “Oh, yeah. We have the most liberal paternity leave on Wall Street—but I would never take it, because if I did, everybody would think I was, you know, wimpy.” And I think there’s great truth to that. So there’s a cultural piece that needs to be looked at. Whereas in the social sector, as a woman leader, you have the opportunity to invent the culture in which you want to work and thrive.

Young people often will come to me and say, “I really want to do this, but first I feel like I need to do A, B, C, D, and E.” In some ways I think we’ve put young people, especially, on a track where they have these expectations that they’re going to do one thing after another because that’s what everybody else does—and then they will get this freedom. And I think there are lots of different paths and that the path isn’t always clear, but you just should start; that work will teach you; and that I can’t imagine a more joyful way of living than a life when where you are serving in the spirit as equally of adventure as you are of change. Q logo

Recommend (60)
  • 25 MAY 2009
    Theresa-Maria Napa
    President
    Right Track Coaching
    Chicago, IL USA

    Jacqueline has a refreshing perspective regarding men and women working internationally and her concern about demoralizing and devaluing men. It serves humanity when men and women do support one another....

    .
    Theresa-Maria Napa
    President
    Right Track Coaching
    Chicago, IL USA

    Jacqueline has a refreshing perspective regarding men and women working internationally and her concern about demoralizing and devaluing men. It serves humanity when men and women do support one another. A major key is in recognizing the gender differences focusing on strengths of both.

    Another point that struck me was her remarkable ability to step back and be an observer of a situation and take responsibility for what’s not working. Jacqueline’s self awareness is evident when she points out while in Rwanda working with small groups of women she says: “...I went in as a leader with pure audaciousness. I didn’t have as much humility in that I just assumed...” She listened to the women’s perspectives and learned that “dignity is so much more important to the human spirit than wealth.”

    She went there to contribute to the leadership of the women with one attitude and caught that something had to change—and it was her own perspective. I believe that as leaders we are teachers and students. We teach what we want to learn and master. She found that “leadership as a way of inspiring, listening, and letting people...grow themselves in their own way.”

    .
  • 11 APRIL 2009
    John Muthee
    Managing Director
    Corporate Social Responsibility Africa Limited
    Nairobi-Kenya

    No matter what Jacqueline writes, I am always left with a feeling of having met one of the women who are bringing big change in small ways...

    .
    John Muthee
    Managing Director
    Corporate Social Responsibility Africa Limited
    Nairobi-Kenya

    No matter what Jacqueline writes (be it a blog, a book, or the transcript of an interview, as in this case), I am always left with a feeling of having met one of the women who are bringing big change in small ways here and there across our African continent. Great dream and a successful avenue for delivering the same.

    .
  • 25 MARCH 2009
    Deepa Mazumdar
    Professor
    National Institute of Bank Management
    Pune, India

    ...I went through the transition of immensely disliking statistics to ending up simply loving it, because I too found that the numbers tell interesting stories. Later, I passed on this belief to my students.

    .
    Deepa Mazumdar
    Professor
    National Institute of Bank Management
    Pune, India

    It was refreshing to read this article before starting to work. I confirm Jacqueline Novogratz’s philosophy of leading people. Regarding numbers, while doing my PhD purely in psychometric model, I went through the transition of immensely disliking statistics to ending up simply loving it, because I too found that the numbers tell interesting stories. Later, I passed on this belief to my students.

    .
  • 25 MARCH 2009
    Sue Van Der Hout
    CEO
    Girlphyte Inc.
    Ontario, Canada

    By skillfully framing what’s transpiring in the women’s space, you are helping men and women better understand how culture is changing in real time.

    .
    Sue Van Der Hout
    CEO
    Girlphyte Inc.
    Ontario, Canada

    McKinsey is succeeding in a singular endeavor: constructing article by article, study by study, a vivid and compelling picture of how women are redefining success, entrepreneurship, and leadership; and in the process are transforming families, and driving world economies and global development. By skillfully framing what’s transpiring in the women’s space, you are helping men and women better understand how culture is changing in real time.

    .
  • 24 MARCH 2009
    Leonor Bazaldua
    Services Marketing Manager
    Dell
    Texas, United States

    You can’t change a society or community without education. You have to start somewhere and its about teaching people to “fish” so that they can break the cycle of poverty.

    .
    Leonor Bazaldua
    Services Marketing Manager
    Dell
    Texas, United States

    I’ve recently started working with a non-profit organization as a volunteer to help improve education and health in Latin America and this publication has really inspired me to do more and reach for those “impossible” goals. You can’t change a society or community without education. You have to start somewhere and its about teaching people to “fish” so that they can break the cycle of poverty. Thank you! Truly inspiring.

    .
Submit Your Comments

The user information you enter into this form will not update your site profile. To update your profile, please visit your profile page.

Subject Women and leadership: Learning from the social sector

*Required

We may publish your comments online and in the print edition of McKinsey Quarterly. Those chosen, which may be edited for length and clarity, will appear along with your name and details, but not your e-mail address. We will use your e-mail address only to send you a confirmation copy of your comments and to notify you if we publish them online.

We value your feedback and will consider it carefully. Nonetheless, we receive so many comments that we cannot acknowledge all of them.

See also:
Preview

New In:
Embed E-mail