close Visitor Edition

The McKinsey Quarterly is the business journal of McKinsey & Company. Register now for immediate access to hundreds of articles.

Subscribe to Premium Membership to read this article

  • Text Size

  • Print

  • Download PDF

  • Link to This

Capital investment: How not to build the TitanicPremium

When faced with a major capital investment, you can save hundreds of millions of dollars. Focus on capital productivity, not just the budget and schedule.

NOVEMBER 1996 • JEREMY CARTER, MENNO VAN DIJK, AND KEN GIBSON

In the early 1990s, one of the world’s leading industrial companies was considering the construction of a new plant which was to cost well in excess of half a billion dollars. However, senior management and the board were uncomfortable with the project’s overall economics and decided to fundamentally rethink the investment. Two years later, the plant was opened at a capital cost of $350 million, 40 percent below the estimate first proposed. Capacity is the same as originally planned, but production unit cost is 30 percent lower than the company’s other operations and control over product quality—a key factor in customer satisfaction—is considerably better. Moreover, the plant is more compact and much simpler to operate and maintain.

To achieve all this, no revolutionary technology was needed, nor any change in product mix specifications. What did change was management’s attitude and approach to the project based on its recognition that more value could be extracted. Management’s insight and determination can dramatically improve the productivity of capital spent on major projects. The key is an approach called clean sheet capital redesign (CSCR). CSCR’s aim is simple: to extract maximum economic value from a project. Starting with a clean sheet, management must...

Premium Membership

Already a Quarterly member? Log in now.
Are you a Firm member or alumnus?

Premium Membership benefits:

  • Access to the entire Quarterly archive, past and present
  • Subscription to the collector’s edition print journal
  • Downloadable PDFs of all articles for offline use
  • Premium Membership FAQs

Start by filling in this form

  • Membership Information
  • Shipping, Billing, & Payment
  • Review & Complete

Country & Membership Term